Status of Minutes


Approved at: 2019-12-12 Meeting notes (CR) DRAFT





Quorum Status

Meeting was quorate

Voting participants

Participant Roster (2016) - Quorum is 5 of 9 as of 2018-07-12

Iain Henderson, Mary Hodder, Harri Honko, Mark Lizar, Jim Pasquale, John Wunderlich, Andrew Hughes, Oscar Santolalla, Richard Gomer

Discussion Items





4 mins
  • Roll call
  • Agenda bashing

5 min
  • Organization updates

Please review these blogs offline for current status on Kantara and all the DG/WG:

There is a new wiki page that will hold all the known implementations of Consent Receipts - Please update the page or inform Andrew of your implementation.

Planning a Member Plenary meeting October 26-ish San Francisco (Friday after IIW)

  • Are there specific cross-group items you'd like to propose to work on?
40 minInteroperable Consent Receipt demo at MyData ConferenceAll

1) Story board discussion - Richard

  • Diagram A: "Get consent receipt"
    • This is the crux of the demo
      • How does the user know they have a CR? 
        • What will a user experience when this happens?
        • Option: make CRs optional to the user (ask them if they want a CR at all)
      • How do they know what to do with at CR?
  • Diagram B: "List Consent Receipts"
    • The location of this diagram is not specific (on purpose)
    • Two parts here:
      • 1) for any given Data Controller, how will they show a list of CR for the user, to that user?
      • 2) open question about consolidate repos for CRs from many data controllers, for the user
      • Use files to store the CRs
      • Use a filename convention (including extension)
      • Use a dedicated folder to hold the downloaded CR files
      • Use a File Manager to get a list of CRs
    • ACTION: Mark: to ask Joss if the receipt storage application is available (from the COEL work)
  • Diagram C: "View a Consent Receipt"
    • Consentua does not currently do this - who does?
    • has a viewer in the product today
      • He will have a sample JSON receipt export available this week
      • At this time, does not want to be a wallet - so no function planned to import general purpose CRs
      • There are too many wallets on the market already
    • OpenConsent is in planning stages of creating a general purpose viewer
      • Current implementation is for 'privacy receipt' which is a subset of a 'consent receipt'
    • Ubisecure
      • Viewer is not planned for this timeframe - they plan to generate CRs for download through the browser
    • Tom Jones has an XSL for diplaying CRs
  • Diagram D: "Move a Consent Receipt"
    • Open question about how to move the receipt from one system to another
      • Export/download/import (browser)
      • Share action (on mobile)
      • Drag-drop (desktop)
      • Email - do we have a MIME-type for Consent Receipts? (Nope, not yet)
      • Q: What about using an API? A: The diagrams are about user interaction patterns, not infrastructure.

2) Issues discussion

No massive show-shoppers at this time

3) Timing for initial testing & location of repo

  • ACTION: Andrew to publish the WG's github repo location
  • ACTION: Andrew to create an publish a Google Drive folder for file exchanges (e.g. Exported CR files)
  • is almost ready to start exporting CRs

  • REMINDER: Jim has circulated links to demo apps for - please take a look and feedback/questions

Next meeting

2018-07-19 same time, same number



From 2018-07-12 call:

Andrew walked through the sequence diagram.

Receipt Reader

 A receipt reader is an application that parses (reads) consent receipts automatically. A reader only handles consent receipts in it's machine readable format  and is a component of some automatic process. 

Receipt Viewer

A receipt viewer is an application that a human uses to interpret the contents of a consent receipt. An application can only be considered a receipt viewer if it presents receipt data in a human readable form.

Receipt Dashboard

A receipt dashboard is an app used by humans to store and manage consent receipts. A user can use their dashboard to perform batch operations on multiple receipts at a time.

 ACTION: All to comment on these starter definitions, on list (note that the text above has already been edited)

From 2018-06-28

From 2018-06-21 call:

From 2018-06-14 call: