Child pages
  • LC eballot to reduce the duration of the Public Review and IPR Review for SAML 2.0 Implementation Profile

Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Rationale 

Justification for classifying these changes as being ‘minor’ (non-breaking):

The revision proposed to the SAML V2.0 Implementation Profile for Federation Interoperability V1.0 is shown below. In Agenda Item 4c(iii) 10 in the Notes from the FIWG meeting of 2019-12-04, this quorate call agreed that a) it is a non-breaking (minor) change, b) did not identify any IPR conflicts c) is a close knit community and any implementations using the current published V1.0 would be known about; and therefore arguably fit for immediate release as V1.1 with the change made.

Revision to SAML V2.0 Implementation Profile for Federation Interoperability V1.0:

In the SAML 2.0 implementation profile, IIP-ALG06 states:
The following DigestMethod algorithms SHOULD be supported for both of the above key transport algorithms for backward compatibility.
*http://www.w3.org/2000/09/xmldsig#sha1

This requirement should be corrected to read:
The following DigestMethod algorithms MUST be supported for both of the above key transport algorithms.
*http://www.w3.org/2000/09/xmldsig#sha1

Specific and most recent commit related to the proposed change is at https://github.com/KantaraInitiative/SAMLprofiles/commit/38154b3b032c9de29044b013329ce5e4e36f6c6d

The FIWG therefore recommends release of this SAML V2.0 Implementation Profile for Federation Interoperability V1.1 at the earliest opportunity on the basis that the revisions per se are minor in nature and do not break any known implementations.

Motion:To reduce the duration of the Public Review period and IPR Review period to zero for the minor material and non-material editorial changes to the SAML V2.0 Implementation Profile for Federation Interoperability.
VOTE
Please cast your vote below. IMPORTANT: in order to record your vote you need to log in into Confluence.
Multivote
idmultivote_inovais_1576003688333
idReduce duration of the Public Comment and IPR Review to zero?
2019-12-10T13:48:08.344-5Yes
2019-12-10T13:48:12.718-5No
2019-12-10T13:48:14.407-5Abstain
Note: In the above e-vote table you will also have access to real-time voting results.


Document:

Version:

Document Date:

Document Download: 

Document URL: 

SAML V2.0 Implementation Profile for Federation Interoperability

1.1

2019-12-12


WG Charter:

Charter

Ballot Opens:

Ballot Closes:

December 17, 2019 


December 24, 2019

Voting Rules:Super Majority vote of the LC
Ballot Information:

KI Operating Procedures SECTION 7.7.1.1: LC Approval, Public Review and IPR Review Period Requirements: 

The LC can, by Super Majority vote of the LC, reduce the duration of, or remove altogether, the IPR Review Period and/or the Public Review period in instances where there is low risk of patent, copyright and applicable IPR issues, and/or low risk of a reduction in quality of the output, and/or the changes are minor and (in the case of criteria, do not break implementations) non-material editorial changes to Group- Approved Recommendations or Technical Specifications. The decision must take into consideration the risk of liability being assumed by reduction or removal of the review period and the impact of changes on affected parties (e.g. Service Providers and Assessors). The decision and rationale shall be reported to the Board of Directors at the next Board of Directors meeting.

Eligible voters:

WG FIRE
WG eGov
WG Federation Interoperability
WG Identity Assurance
WG User-Managed Access
WG Consent & Information Sharing
WG Consent Management Solutions
WG Healthcare Identity Assurance