[KI-LC] Mail List Policy

Paul Madsen paulmadsen at rogers.com
Fri May 22 16:09:16 PDT 2009

my interpretation of the primary goal for any such email policy is to 
prevent IP contamination - this possible if (mere) subscribers were able 
to post to the list.

If that is indeed the case, why differentiate between levels of read 
access by distinguishing between real time & digest? Surely it's 
immaterial to the primary goal?


Brett McDowell wrote:
> Forgive the cross-post (if you are one of the lucky folks who are 
> subscribed to both of these lists).  I'm sending this to both lists 
> because the Board of Trustees assigned an action item to me to work on 
> a Mail List Policy, and on the Leadership Council meeting today they 
> shared their opinions and also made it clear they wanted to be a part 
> of this process.  One LC member actually felt this should be in the 
> Operating Procedures vs. a stand-alone policy.  So, that's why I'm 
> copying both.
> This is more of an introduction.  Joni is going to circulate the first 
> draft of the policy next week.  I'm just going to introduce what I 
> believe is the fundamental topic for debate, and perhaps Joni should 
> hold off until this issue is debated a bit more via email.
> The only issue I've heard in my talks with BoT and LC that might fall 
> short of a consensus, is the issue of whether subscribers (who are not 
> members of a group) get an option to receive every email, or only a 
> daily digest of email.  That's it.  Everybody agrees with every other 
> aspect of the policy as discussed in the two calls.
> Perhaps we should begin simply by asking someone to clarify why they 
> believe non-member subscribers should receive each email in real-time 
> even though their responses are moderated (i.e., they cannot send to 
> the list unless they are participants in the group so why trigger that 
> Pavlovian trigger to attempt a response).  That's just my suggestion 
> for where to start the email discussion, if you'd rather choose a 
> different starting point, simply chime in.
> Kind Regards,
> Brett McDowell | +1.413.652.1248 | http://info.brettmcdowell.com
> _______________________________________________
> LC mailing list
> LC at kantarainitiative.org
> http://kantarainitiative.org/mailman/listinfo/lc_kantarainitiative.org

More information about the LC mailing list