Kantara IdP Selection Work Group Teleconference

Date and Time

Date: Tuesday, March 10, 2010
Time: 13:00 PST | 15:00 EST | 22:00 UTC | 23.00 CEST (Time Chart)

Dial in: Private number

Attendees

• Philippe Clément (Orange)
• Jonas Hogberg (Ericsson) (observer)
• Benoit Bailleux (Orange)
• Gael Gourmelen (Orange)
• Sampo Kellomaki (TAS3/Symlabs)
• Kenneth Dagg (Government of Canada)
• Ingo Friese (Deutsche Telekom)
• Gael Gourmelen (Orange)
• Dervla O'Reilly
• Shin Adachi (NTT)
• Fulup Ar Foll (SUN)
• Paul Madsen

Apologies

• None

The group reached quorum for this face-to-face meeting.

Agenda

1. Roll call
2. last minutes approval
3. Proposed Models
4. Achievements and Roadmap proposal
5. Unified Charter for ULX & IdP Selection WGs
6. AOB

Minutes

1. Roll call

2. Last minutes approved

3. Proposed Models

please refer to this link for the presentation: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/download/attachments/37751102/IDPSelection+Agenda+v0.ppt

Different models, new technical flows between entities - a better understanding of the slides is needed.  Gael and Benoit added one slide at each model with functional view - the functional relations between the RP, ISA (IdP Selector agent) and IdP.  Functional relations are thus better defined. 

• action point: Gael to define pros & cons for each model for the next call

4. Achievements and Roadmap proposal

4.1 Metadata discovery

please refer to this link: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/download/attachments/41027190/IDP+Metadata+Status+and+Evo+v02.ppt

Display metadata – from analysis, do we have everything needed? Display name and logo? Or do we need more information?

• action point: Gael to check the information is already included.

IdP Display metadata: extension to the YADIS - Gael to check with Peter Davis.

IdP Display infocard: N/A

IdPs supported ACs and ALs
– SAML

• Open ID – not sure if there is authentication for this one
• InfoCard – just considered as claims, eg. ICAM Levels 1, 2 & 3.

IdPs supported attributes/claims

• SAML
• Open ID
• InfoCard – all known attributes of the user

4.2. Proposal for the integration of an ISA in the RP

please refer to this link: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/download/attachments/41027188/Technical_way_to_integrate_the_ISA-v0.1.doc

5. # Unified Charter for ULX & IdP Selection WGs

Work overlaps, combine groups and updating the charter to reflect this. (need to highlight the protocol touchpoints that UX and GUI use - go beyond the user experience, show integreted user interface enabling....). The charter has to be interested both in the experience and the infrastructure. Where text reads "integrated user interface" add text "and an enabling technical framework" that best guides a person through the login lifecycle of a website. This does not include first registration, but does include logging in during return visits, [required consents] as well as logging out. It emcompasses the process of the selection of the user's Identity Provider as defined in the Liberty Identity Provider Selector MRD. Assumed is a range of initial conditions, protocols, and relationships between the application, the ISA and identity services.

P.4. Add OAUTH to list in next paragraph.

P. 4, 3rd bullet. Developing prototype implementations of the user interface and enabling technical frameworks

P.6 (4) Draft Technical Specifications, 2nd bullet point. "Login Metadata Discovery - A mechanism whereby a browser with an add-on or an ISA in the network can discover the supported/preferred login method(s) of the Relying Party"

P.6, last paragraph. This Work Group will target producing use cases and requirements including those of the Liberty Alliance Identity Provider Selection WG.

decision:  Common Charter modified during this meeting is approved to be circulated to ULX WG

common charter accessible through this link: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/download/attachments/41027193/Kantara+Common+charter+v0+3.doc

• Action Point: Philippe to circulate the Charter proposal to Paul Trevithick (ULX WG).

6. AOB - none

Next Meeting

• Date: Tuesday, March 30, 2010

• Location	Local time	Time zone
  (U.S.A. - California)	mardi 30 mars 2010, 07 h 30 m 00	UTC-7 hours PDT
  (France)	mardi 30 mars 2010, 16 h 30 m 00	UTC+2 hours CEST
  Corresponding UTC (GMT)	mardi 30 mars 2010, 14 h 30 m 00

Dial in: US Dial-In: +1-201-793-9022 | Room Code: 2954214 - Skype: +9900827042954214